[pdftex] please make PDF ID field more deterministic
nicolas at debian.org
Sun May 17 21:09:45 CEST 2015
It would be convenient that, by default or with appropriate options,
PDFTeX produces reproducible results from given input files. You may
find some motivations at
Despite the wording, few problems are specific to Debian.
By default, the CreationDate and ModDate fields reflect the build
date, but this can be overriden with
Unfortunately, the implementation of the ID field is an MD5 hash of
the build date, the output directory path and the output file name.
A first suggestion is to avoid generating the ID field, which is
optional and not widely used.
A less intrusive option would provide a new primitive like
My favorite suggestion would let the default ID depend on
- the configurable CreationDate instead of a random gmtime().
- the output file name only, ignoring its directory path.
Even if everybody starts to use the ID field, I hardly imagine how
these changes could create a collision.
The attached patch demonstrates the idea on
It requires a trivial, but less readable change, in order to actually
compile: swap the declarations of the start_time_str global variable
and the printID() procedure.
Please CC me, I do not read this list permanently.
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Size: 1113 bytes
Desc: not available
More information about the pdftex